Western Bulldog Buku Khamis was the first player pinged, as he appeared to be pushed out of a marking contest on the wing by Collingwood opponent Isaac Quaynor ...
You’ve got to chop it off at the knees and say nothing is acceptable,” he said. The problem is if the umpires want to waver on their interpretation at any stage, then the players get a bit confused. Is this the new standard?” he said. You’ve got to chop it off at the knees and say nothing is acceptable,” he said. The problem is if the umpires want to waver on their interpretation at any stage, then the players get a bit confused. “I think maybe we need a reassertion of what is going to be considered dissent. I think it will be [cleaned up by the finals]. Is this the new standard?” he said. “I think maybe we need a reassertion of what is going to be considered dissent. I think it will be [cleaned up by the finals]. “They’re giving instructions to the umpires so let’s not be hard on them either. “For five weeks we haven’t seen them being paid at all so that is the confusion.
Collingwood and the Western Bulldogs face off at Marvel Stadium. Follow along with our live blog for all the big moments and post-game reactions.
The Eagles pulled the wrong rein from the start with their attitude towards COVID-19, and they had a few own goals in the off-season. Adam Simpson has been a very good coach, but there is a disconnect between him and the players. Aaron Naughton has kicked two, so too Buku Khamis, who is making a good fist of his chance to prove himself as the Dogs’ second tall forward. They were ruthless in the first quarter, winning the first six centre clearances as they set up what appears to be a match-winning lead. Is there an issue with selection, and younger players not being given a go? Where have the Dogs of tonight been all year?
Collingwood and the Western Bulldogs face off at Marvel Stadium. Follow along with our live blog for all the big moments and post-game reactions.
I feel like we’ve been able to play our brand inconsistently throughout games and I feel like we’ve been in most games of the year, and today I felt like we brought it from the start and we were able to sustain it for a bit. For us to play defensively the way we did, it was first-class defence. Checkers looks sore tonight and he’s had to carry a lot of the load for the group. A couple of weeks and we’ll see him back. We have a lot of work to do around that. I know it’s been talked about that we haven’t started the way we wanted to but, yeah, good win tonight. We lost a little territory from it and lost a lot of contests. But out of necessity and needing a second ruck opportunity at AFL level, we started to play him forward and pinch him at the ruck at state league level and then he started kicking goals. You’ve had it taped up most of the year. It was a poor start wasn’t it by us and an exceptional start by them. Buku as a young fella played a lot of his junior games as a forward. Through hardship and change, opportunities are created so it’s good to see some of the boys who haven’t played a lot of AFL footy play really critical roles.
Treloar, key forward Aaron Naughton, Josh Dunkley and exciting newcomer Buku Khamis all kicked three goals each for the Bulldogs. Match Stats ...
In a concern for the Bulldogs, Naughton appeared troubled by a knee injury for most of the game and hobbled to the bench late in the final quarter. Treloar now has a 2-0 record for the Bulldogs playing Collingwood after he was controversially traded out of the Magpies at the end of 2020. Collingwood steadied after the first quarter onslaught to remain in the contest until midway through the third term before the Bulldogs again pulled away to lead by 46 points at the final break and prevail 14.15 (99) to 7.9 (51).
THE WESTERN Bulldogs are one step closer to getting their season back on track, defeating Collingwood by 48 points under the roof at Marvel Stadium.
Henry continued to present, and kicked another behind in the first term, before having another couple of shots at goal in the second quarter for one behind and another no score. It was a ‘What could have been?’ type of night for young Collingwood forward Ollie Henry. After missing his first shot early in the game, Henry marked 30 metres out from goal but passed the ball to Jordan De Goey, with the Pies messing up the chance and it being whisked to the other end for a Bulldogs goal. Injuries have made for some opportunities in the Bulldogs’ line-up and Khamis is taking his inside the club’s forward line. They kicked the first six goals of the game and opened up a 39-point lead over the Pies before Collingwood had registered its first goal. Smith will be well and truly leading the Bulldogs’ best and fairest after nine rounds but will also have likely picked up a few Brownlow Medal votes as his ascent continues with a full-time midfield role. In all of the Dogs wins this year – over Sydney, North Melbourne, Essendon and the Pies – he has been important and could have a breakout year in Brownlow voting.
The Western Bulldogs' AFL season is back on track after an early blast set up a vital and convincing 48-point victory over Collingwood at Marvel Stadium.
Magpies defender Jack Madgen looks set for a long stint on the sidelines after hurting his shoulder in the second quarter and was subbed out for Finlay Macrae. The night started in tough fashion for Collingwood after captain Scott Pendlebury was a late withdrawal through illness. Treloar now has a 2-0 record for the Bulldogs playing Collingwood after he was controversially traded out of the Magpies at the end of 2020.
Collingwood and the Western Bulldogs face off at Marvel Stadium. Follow along with our live blog for all the big moments and post-game reactions.
The AFL's controversial umpire dissent rule has once again come under scrutiny following a couple of “ridiculous” decisions during Friday evening's clash ...
“They’re giving instructions to the umpires so let’s not be hard on them either. There’s a difference between abuse and players showing emotion in the moment.” We had a base line. Need to get our heads around this properly.— Andy Maher (@AndyMaherDFA) May 13, 2022 If you see the arms go up, that is some form of dissent but it’s hard to expect players to completely turn off the emotion as soon as the whistle goes.” Still a 50m penalty. Speaking on Fox Footy, Hawthorn legend Jason Dunstall argued: “I thought De Goey in particular was a little bit stiff because he was about to go off and then literally harnessed himself back in and then actually stopped but you could see initially he was about to throw the arms up. Now it’s hard to know where we are again.” It’s great to help umpires, but punishing players for marginal stuff like we’ve seen tonight isn’t fair on them. A similar incident too place in the fourth quarter when Collingwood forward Jordan De Goey threw his arms in the air after tackling Josh Dunkley, only for the Bulldogs to be awarded a 50m penalty. The AFL’s controversial umpire dissent rule has once again come under scrutiny following a couple of “ridiculous” decisions during Friday evening’s clash between the Western Bulldogs and Collingwood at Marvel Stadium. The AFL’s controversial umpire dissent rule has once again come under fire following a couple of “ridiculous” decisions on Friday evening.
The Dogs accounted for the Pies to the tune of 48-points but there were plenty of talking points in this one. HB has the Big Questions.
It was a momentum killer, and if I am being honest, it is the second implementation of the rule for the evening that made me want to throw my hands up and walk away. It was an impressive display that saw the big names star, and often left the Pies chasing tail… Apologies to Magpie fans for stealing a line from their song to open the review, but it sets the tone well.
"I feel for them at times. This is an emotional game. They are not robots." Jordan De Goey cops a 50 for dissent (Fox Footy).
"They're giving instructions to the umpires so let's not be hard on them either. There was a big focus after round three, then it drifted away." "It is incumbent on us at the elite level to set the standards of behaviour for all levels of the game," Scott said in April. "I feel for them at times. They are not robots." "For five weeks we haven't seen them being paid at all so that is the confusion.